Should GitHub Copilot Approve Your Pull Requests?

GitHub has changed what Copilot code review can do.
Since September 2026, GitHub Copilot can do more than review a pull request and leave comments. Administrators can now allow it to submit an approving review, and can separately allow that approval to count towards a repository’s merge requirements.
The question is no longer simply whether Copilot is good enough to review code. Many engineering teams already use it as an additional reviewer. The more important question is whether an AI reviewer should be given approval authority - and, if so, where.
A reviewer provides analysis and engineering feedback. Approval authority is a control over whether a change is allowed to progress through the software delivery process.
For platform and security leaders, Copilot approval should therefore be treated less like another AI feature and more like any other delegated privilege: start with a clear boundary, understand the blast radius, and grant authority only where the surrounding controls justify it.
So what actually changed, mechanically?
GitHub gives you three layers of control, and they stack:

A couple of details matter if you're the one configuring this. If new commits get pushed after Copilot approves, that approval gets dismissed automatically, the same as it would for a human reviewer, so you'd need to request a fresh review. And this is still a public preview feature, available on Copilot Pro, Pro+, Max, Business, and Enterprise plans, so treat today's settings screen as version one, not the final word.
Why does this matter even if you haven't touched the setting?
Because you're probably already relying on Copilot more than you'd guess. GitHub reported in March 2026 that Copilot's code review had grown tenfold in under a year and was already handling more than one in five reviews on the platform. Most engineering teams already lean on it as a working second reviewer on a big share of their pull requests.
Until three weeks ago, none of that mattered from a risk standpoint, because a human still had to click approve regardless of how good Copilot's comments were. That's the part that's now optional. And a team that's short on reviewer capacity, which is most teams, has an obvious reason to flip the org-wide switch and call the backlog problem solved. The mistake isn't turning it on. It's treating that as one decision instead of a dozen smaller ones, each with a different amount of risk riding on it.
A good reviewer and an accountable approver aren't the same job
Here's a distinction that's easy to skip past: a required-approvals rule doesn't exist to catch bugs. Tests and static analysis do that job, and usually do it better than any reviewer, human or otherwise. A required approval exists as a segregation-of-duties control, meaning it's proof that a second, accountable person looked at the change before it went out. That's a different function from "did anyone check this for mistakes."
Copilot has already earned its place as a second pair of eyes. What changed on 1 September is whether it also gets to be the accountable signature. Those are two different jobs, and it's worth deciding, deliberately, which one you're handing over.
A simple framework for deciding
Once you've drawn that line, the rest is about scoping it well. Here's how we'd break it down.
1. Where Copilot's approval earns its keep
Low blast radius, high volume, and already backed up by real checks: dependency bumps, generated code, docs-only changes, test-only changes, and internal tooling repos with solid GHAS or static analysis coverage. The diffs are narrow, the failure modes are well understood, and a tired human clicking approve on the fortieth dependency-bump PR of the week is honestly a bigger risk than a consistent AI check. In these repos, the rubber stamp already existed. Copilot's approval just makes it consistent instead of fatigued.
2. Where a human has to stay in the loop, no exceptions
Production authentication and identity code, payment and financial calculation logic, anything touching customer data, infrastructure-as-code that reaches production, cryptography, and access-control changes. This holds no matter how good Copilot's judgement gets, because an AI approver can't be held accountable in any way an auditor cares about. It can't be interviewed about intent, named in an incident review, or held to a professional standard. If you work in insurance, financial services, or government, which describes most of our clients across APAC, this isn't a nice-to-have distinction. It's the difference between a control that satisfies an audit and one that doesn't.
3. What happens when AI reviews AI-written code
There's a narrower risk worth calling out on its own: a pull request written largely by a Copilot coding agent, then reviewed and approved by Copilot code review. Independent review works because a second reviewer brings different assumptions and catches different things. Two humans missing the same bug independently is unlikely. Two systems trained on overlapping patterns are far more likely to miss it together. So the guardrail here is simple: if a PR's diff was substantially AI-authored, require a human for approval, even if the repo's default policy would normally let Copilot sign off.
4. Treating file paths like you'd treat access control
This is where GitHub's file-path scoping is genuinely useful rather than a nice extra. The instinct should be the same one you'd use for identity and access anywhere else: least privilege by default, then a deliberate, documented decision to widen it.
Foodstuffs North Island applied this principle at the governance layer, establishing clear policies for repository creation, forking, and token lifetimes across a federated engineering organisation of 125+ developers, instead of leaving those decisions to individual teams.
Copilot's approval scope deserves the same treatment. Any file path with a named human CODEOWNER for regulated or high-risk logic should sit outside Copilot's approval scope, full stop.
5. What good governance looks like now
Branch protection was built on an assumption that just broke: every entity capable of satisfying a required-approvals rule is human, identifiable, and accountable. So governance needs an actual answer to a question it never had to ask before: what authority does each kind of reviewer carry, and why? A workable model splits that decision the same way GitHub does:
Enterprise admins set the default posture: off, unless there's a specific business case for delegating the decision down.
Org admins decide which categories of repo are even eligible to opt in, tied to a risk tier, rather than leaving that call to each repo admin individually. Production and regulated-scope repos stay off the table regardless of what a local admin would prefer.
Repo admins configure file-path scope within that tier, and write down why in the repo's contributing guide, because this is now a control an auditor will ask about.
One catch worth knowing up front: GitHub doesn't give you a built-in "risk tier" concept, so mapping repos to one takes custom properties, repository rulesets, or a policy-as-code layer someone has to actually build. That's usually where this kind of initiative stalls if nobody owns it.
Quick reference

What to actually do this week
What GitHub handed every admin isn't really a security question. It's a governance design question wearing a settings toggle, and the answer should track what Copilot is actually accountable for right now, which is nothing an auditor can point to. Used well, its approval authority takes friction out of reviews that were already rubber stamps. Used carelessly, it quietly removes the one control built specifically to put an accountable human between a risky change and production.
So pull the list of repos where Copilot is already your de facto primary reviewer, and go path by path deciding which of them should also get approval authority. Don't just inherit whatever the org-wide default ends up being.
If this raises questions about your own governance model, speak to the Furo team today.


Comments